1 0:12:50 O'BRIEN, Kevin East Cork AC M
2 0:13:02 MCKEOWN, Kieran Watergrasshill AC M40
3 0:13:14 O'SHEA, Barry Midleton AC M
16 0:14:34 SANTRY, Fiona East Cork AC F
27 0:15:13 O'BRIEN, Claire Watergrasshill AC F
35 0:16:17 O'NEILL, Nollaig Leevale AC F45
Full results below...
Cloyne Commons Challenge 4k Series Race3
Sunday 20 January 2019. 9:30 am
Results for All Competitors in finish order. Pace Race Race
Place Time Name Team Race Age Category min/mile
1 0:12:50 O'BRIEN, Kevin East Cork AC M :02:12. 922 1
2 0:13:02 MCKEOWN, Kieran Watergrasshill AC M40 :22:39. 941 2
3 0:13:14 O'SHEA, Barry Midleton AC M :43:06. 276 3
4 0:13:23 FLAITHEARTAIGH, Naoise Bandon AC MJ :43:26. 950 4
5 0:13:29 HARTY, Brian East Cork AC M :23:40. 106 5
6 0:13:33 SWORDS, Graham East Cork AC M :50:29. 979 6
7 0:13:36 HARRINGTON, Shane East Cork AC M :10:36. 955 7
8 0:13:45 INCE, Ken Watergrasshill AC M :10:56. 130 8
9 0:13:55 SHEEHAN, Nigel Youghal AC M :17:58. 317 9
10 0:13:59 CROWLEY, Tim East Cork AC M :44:47. 63 10
11 0:14:00 O'BRIEN, Stephen East Cork AC M :51:30. 925 11
12 0:14:03 HANNON, Tim Midleton AC M :11:36. 103 12
13 0:14:04 HAYES, Frank East Cork AC M45 :18:19. 387 13
14 0:14:22 MULLANE, Conor Watergrasshill AC M40 :18:59. 199 14
15 0:14:24 KELLY, Chris Aghada RC M :32:24. 142 15
16 0:14:34 SANTRY, Fiona East Cork AC F :39:26. 937 16
17 0:14:38 GILTINAN, Donal Unattached M :06:15. 936 17
18 0:14:41 SMITH, Kevin Midleton AC M40 :26:22. 319 18
19 0:14:42 CREMIN, Mike Unattached M :33:04. 47 19
20 0:14:46 BRUTON, Pat Unattached M50 :59:53. 976 20
21 0:14:48 COLLINS, Trevor Naas AC M40 :13:18. 33 21
22 0:14:52 LONGAN, John Unattached M :40:07. 165 22
23 0:14:54 LANDERS, Brian Youghal AC M45 :53:31. 150 23
24 0:15:00 COSTIGAN, Pat St Catherines AC M45 0:33:45 41 24
25 0:15:09 NICHOLSON, Edmund Youghal AC M45 1:34:05 217 25
26 0:15:11 BYRNE, Edmund Togher AC M45 1:47:29 983 26
27 0:15:13 O'BRIEN, Claire Watergrasshill AC F 2:00:54 225 27
28 0:15:34 DORGAN, Declan Midleton AC M40 4:21:41 73 28
29 0:15:38 TIERNEY, Conor East Cork AC M40 4:48:30 330 29
30 0:15:56 MEADE, Eric East Cork AC M50 6:49:11 192 30
31 0:15:58 MULCAHY, John St Catherines AC M 7:02:35 198 31
32 0:16:00 DUNPHY, John Eagle AC M45 7:16:00 951 32
33 0:16:03 POMPHRETT, Eoin Aghada RC M45 7:36:06 290 33
34 0:16:09 WOODS, Dermot St Finbarrs AC M40 8:16:20 934 34
35 0:16:17 O'NEILL, Nollaig Leevale AC F45 9:09:58 940 35
36 0:16:22 CRONIN, Tim Unattached M40 9:43:29 59 36
37 0:16:23 MCCARTHY, Denis East Cork AC M55 9:50:11 178 37
38 0:16:24 KELLEHER, Mark Unattached M 9:56:54 140 38
39 0:16:24 HEALY, Declan Unattached M45 9:56:54 110 39
40 0:16:28 THOMAS, Matthew East Cork AC M 0:23:43 967 40
41 0:16:34 MCDONALD, Michael Ballymore Cobh AC M50 1:03:56 179 41
42 0:16:39 BARRETT, David Unattached M 1:37:27 994 42
43 0:16:42 MOORE, Tom Cobh Tri M55 1:57:34 194 43
44 0:16:47 FORDE, Nadine Leevale AC F50 2:31:05 805 44
45 0:16:48 HAYES, Conor St Catherines AC MJ 2:37:48 388 45
46 0:16:51 TWOHIG, Dan Midleton AC M40 2:57:54 331 46
47 0:16:52 MEYLER, Shane Ballymore Cobh AC M40 3:04:37 745 47
48 0:16:54 CASHMAN, John Midleton AC M50 3:18:01 935 48
49 0:17:01 HEAVIN, Darragh Unattached MJ 4:04:57 114 49
50 0:17:05 HORGAN, Trevor Unattached M40 4:31:46 128 50
51 0:17:07 O'LEARY, Denis Aghada RC M40 4:45:10 971 51
52 0:17:09 O'SHEA, Colm Unattached M45 4:58:35 277 52
53 0:17:10 LEAHY, Eileen Midleton AC F 5:05:17 153 53
54 0:17:11 O'CONNOR, Michael Carrigtwohill AC M40 5:11:59 245 54
55 0:17:11 SPILLANE, Colm Fota RC M 5:11:59 320 55
56 0:17:13 O'CALLAGHAN, Declan Unattached M40 5:25:24 968 56
57 0:17:15 COSTINE, Diarmuid Unattached M 5:38:48 42 57
58 0:17:19 O'BRIEN, Michael Aghada RC M 6:05:37 230 58
59 0:17:25 CRONIN, Carthaigh Unattached MJ 6:45:51 49 59
60 0:17:29 O'DWYER, Barry Midleton AC M45 7:12:40 949 60
61 0:17:32 JUR, Greg Unattached M 7:32:47 131 61
62 0:17:36 NORRIS, Séan Aghada RC M40 7:59:36 221 62
63 0:17:47 MURPHY, Des Unattached M40 9:13:20 205 63
64 0:17:56 HEAVIN, Conall Unattached MJ 0:13:41 113 64
65 0:17:56 HEAVIN, Aidan Unattached M40 0:13:41 112 65
66 0:17:57 DRENNAN, Sally Midleton AC F50 0:20:23 79 66
67 0:17:58 TWOMEY, Aiden Aghada RC M40 0:27:05 335 67
68 0:18:04 O'LEARY, Pat Unattached M50 1:07:19 361 68
69 0:18:06 O'FLYNN, Laura Unattached F35 1:20:43 255 69
70 0:18:07 O'DONOGHUE, Donal Unattached M50 1:27:25 249 70
71 0:18:11 CASEY, JJ Unattached M60 1:54:14 26 71
72 0:18:17 LYONS, Stephen Unattached M50 2:34:28 953 72
73 0:18:19 FRAZER, Eoghan Unattached MJ 2:47:52 999 73
74 0:18:20 BARRYMURPHY, John Unattached M 2:54:35 380 74
75 0:18:21 AHERNE, Marcus Aghada RC M45 3:01:17 4 75
76 0:18:22 RYALL, Noel Unattached M50 3:07:59 306 76
77 0:18:26 ERFURTH, Anna Carrigtwohill AC F35 3:34:48 83 77
78 0:18:28 MCLEOD, Liam Unattached M40 3:48:13 187 78
79 0:18:29 ABERNETHY, Fergal Ballintotis Fit4Life M45 3:54:55 1 79
80 0:18:30 FLEMING, Ciaran Unattached M 4:01:37 987 80
81 0:18:32 FLEMING, Daniel Unattached M 4:15:02 986 81
82 0:18:39 QUINN, Peter Ballymore Cobh AC M55 5:01:57 296 82
83 0:18:45 HICKEY, Aiden Unattached M 5:42:11 120 83
84 0:18:45 HENNESSY, Tom Youghal AC M55 5:42:11 118 84
85 0:18:45 O'REGAN, Eddie Youghal AC M60 5:42:11 270 85
86 0:18:47 O'CONNOR, Liam Unattached M50 5:55:35 244 86
87 0:18:48 WALSH, Robert Aghada RC M40 6:02:18 978 87
88 0:19:00 WALSH, Pat Unattached M55 7:22:45 342 88
89 0:19:02 O'CALLAGHAN, Mark Unattached M45 7:36:09 235 89
90 0:19:03 DENNIS, Ciara Carrigtwohill AC F35 7:42:51 71 90
91 0:19:04 ROCHE, Pat St Catherines AC M 7:49:34 304 91
92 0:19:09 BEIRNE, Michael Midleton AC M55 8:23:05 11 92
93 0:19:15 MCCARTHY, Brian Unattached M 9:03:18 973 93
94 0:19:18 WHEALAN, Finn Unattached MJ 9:23:25 963 94
95 0:19:22 COTTER, Greg Unattached M45 9:50:14 45 95
96 0:19:22 WORRALL, Alma Ballymore Cobh AC F45 9:50:14 379 96
97 0:19:23 O'RIORDAN, Trish Unattached F40 9:56:56 997 97
98 0:19:23 CODY, Tom Midleton AC M60 9:56:56 31 98
99 0:19:24 DE BARRA, Mary Unattached F50 0:03:39 70 99
100 0:19:25 O'DONOGHUE, Colm Road Runners Club MJ 0:10:21 248 100
101 0:19:26 O'DONOGHUE, Kevin Aghada RC MJ 0:17:03 250 101
102 0:19:27 BRENNAN, John Unattached M 0:23:45 985 102
103 0:19:28 BUCKLEY, Julie Watergrasshill AC F35 0:30:28 376 103
104 0:19:29 MAHONY, Katherine Carinavar AC FJ 0:37:10 360 104
105 0:19:30 O'SULLIVAN, Derek Unattached M45 0:43:52 280 105
106 0:19:33 KIERANS, Paul Midleton AC M50 1:03:59 801 106
107 0:19:37 RYAN, Cormac Unattached MJ 1:30:48 309 107
108 0:19:39 MCGRATH, Aine Unattached FJ 1:44:12 182 108
109 0:19:40 KEARNEY, Bartholomew Leevale AC M60 1:50:55 138 109
110 0:19:45 MCCARTHY, David Youghal AC M55 2:24:26 177 110
111 0:19:47 LYNCH, James Unattached M 2:37:50 382 111
112 0:19:49 KEANE, Kathleen St Catherines AC F 2:51:15 136 112
113 0:19:51 GRIFFIN, Cormac Unattached M40 3:04:39 385 113
114 0:19:58 COUGHLAN, Mags Unattached F45 3:51:35 46 114
115 0:20:06 WALSHE, John Road Runners Club M65 4:45:13 344 115
116 0:20:07 PENDER, Leilia Ballymore Cobh AC F40 4:51:55 286 116
117 0:20:09 O'DONOVAN, Laura Unattached FJ 5:05:20 252 117
118 0:20:19 MORLEY, Alan Midleton AC M40 6:12:22 933 118
119 0:20:20 O'HAODAIN, Fionan Midleton AC M45 6:19:05 757 119
120 0:20:23 FITZGERALD, Gerry Midleton AC M45 6:39:11 88 120
121 0:20:25 SULLIVAN, Emer Carrigtwohill AC F40 6:52:36 323 121
122 0:20:25 RYALL, Eileen Unattached F50 6:52:36 1000 122
123 0:20:28 BARRY, Aidan Unattached M50 7:12:43 995 123
124 0:20:30 POWER, Joe Unattached M60 7:26:07 293 124
125 0:20:31 MCGRATH, Ciara Unattached F 7:32:49 969 125
126 0:20:31 MCGRATH, Felicity Unattached F40 7:32:49 183 126
127 0:20:39 O'SULLIVAN, Tony Unattached M45 8:26:27 283 127
128 0:20:44 O'DONAVAN, Patrick Unattached M40 8:59:59 247 128
129 0:20:46 POMPHRETT, Trystan Midleton AC MJ 9:13:23 291 129
130 0:20:48 DRENNAN, Barry Midleton AC M60 9:26:48 78 130
131 0:20:48 FITZGERALD, Aoife Unattached FJ 9:26:48 84 131
132 0:20:50 WHELAN, Martin Unattached M50 9:40:12 350 132
133 0:20:53 ROBERTS, Joyce Unattached F40 0:00:19 301 133
134 0:20:57 O'NEILL, Yvonne Unattached F 0:27:08 268 134
135 0:20:58 LAWTON, Kevin Unattached M45 0:33:50 151 135
136 0:21:02 HEALY, Maria Unattached F 1:00:39 981 136
137 0:21:04 LEAHY, Mary Unattached FJ 1:14:04 155 137
138 0:21:06 O'KEEFFE, Mark Youghal AC M50 1:27:28 259 138
139 0:21:10 KENNEDY, Yvonne Unattached F40 1:54:17 146 139
140 0:21:15 POSTROZNY, Janusz Unattached M 2:27:48 292 140
141 0:21:15 O'CONNOR, James Unattached MJ 2:27:48 243 141
142 0:21:22 MURPHY, Christine Midleton AC F45 3:14:44 201 142
143 0:21:22 O'KEEFFE, Proinnsias Unattached M55 3:14:44 261 143
144 0:21:23 KELLEHER CAREW, Linda Ballintotis Fit4Life F35 3:21:26 975 144
145 0:21:25 CAREW, TJ Ballintotis Fit4Life M 3:34:51 974 145
146 0:21:26 MURTAGH, Shane Unattached MJ 3:41:33 391 146
147 0:21:28 MURTAGH, John Unattached M50 3:54:58 390 147
148 0:21:29 MCGRATH, Aileen Midleton AC FJ 4:01:40 181 148
149 0:21:33 HEGARTY, Clodagh Aghada RC F45 4:28:29 116 149
150 0:21:36 DOLPHIN, Kevin Unattached M 4:48:36 982 150
151 0:21:46 POMPHRETT, Saoirse Unattached FJ 5:55:38 972 151
152 0:21:47 WIMPENNY, Daire Unattached MJ 6:02:20 353 152
153 0:21:48 HEGARTY, Linda Aghada RC F45 6:09:03 117 153
154 0:21:52 MCGREGOR, Catriona Midleton AC F55 6:35:52 185 154
155 0:21:55 MORRISON, Tom Unattached M40 6:55:58 196 155
156 0:21:56 GOLDEN, Annabel Unattached F45 7:02:41 980 156
157 0:21:57 WIMPENNY, Stephen Unattached M45 7:09:23 355 157
158 0:22:02 O'GORMAN, Shirley Aghada RC F45 7:42:54 378 158
159 0:22:03 FITZGERALD, Emma Unattached FJ 7:49:36 86 159
160 0:22:08 O'REGAN, Celia Youghal AC F50 8:23:08 269 160
161 0:22:09 FITZGERALD, Claire Midleton AC F40 8:29:50 85 161
162 0:22:13 RIGNEY, Miriam Unattached F45 8:56:39 807 162
163 0:22:16 RYAN, Bridget Ballintotis Fit4Life F45 9:16:46 308 163
164 0:22:18 LAWTON, Maura Unattached F50 9:30:10 152 164
165 0:22:21 PERRY, Anne-marie Midleton AC F45 9:50:17 287 165
166 0:22:36 DOYLE, Karl Ballymore Cobh AC M 1:30:51 76 166
167 0:22:45 MURPHY, Denise St Nicholas AC F45 2:31:11 204 167
168 0:22:48 FORDE, Claire Fota Island AC F35 2:51:18 95 168
169 0:22:56 PHELAN, Ruth Ballymore Cobh AC F55 3:44:56 288 169
170 0:22:56 CRONIN, Sabhdh Unattached FJ 3:44:56 56 170
171 0:23:04 O'CONNELL, Sarah St Catherines AC FJ 4:38:34 238 171
172 0:23:05 HAYES, Ciara St Catherines AC FJ 4:45:16 389 172
173 0:23:08 LEAHY, Martin Ballintotis Fit4Life M45 5:05:23 154 173
174 0:23:12 HOGAN, Enda Midleton AC F40 5:32:12 122 174
175 0:23:18 LENIHAN, Sadie St Catherines AC FJ 6:12:25 163 175
176 0:23:19 O'CONNOR, Ella St Catherines AC FJ 6:19:07 242 176
177 0:23:23 KOHLER, Ian Midleton AC M70 6:45:56 149 177
178 0:23:30 RYAN, Justin Unattached M45 7:32:52 311 178
179 0:23:32 O'CONNOR, Claire Unattached F45 7:46:17 241 179
180 0:23:42 NOLAN OWERS, Tanya Aghada RC F35 8:53:19 218 180
181 0:23:46 RYAN, Therese Aghada RC F45 9:20:08 315 181
182 0:23:55 NAVIN, Bernadette Ballymore Cobh AC F45 0:20:28 216 182
183 0:23:56 BUNNY, Phil Unattached M 0:27:11 964 183
184 0:24:03 O'MAHONY, Sean Unattached M40 1:14:06 961 184
185 0:24:03 LEHANE, Mike Unattached M40 1:14:06 962 185
186 0:24:07 REARDON, Jakob Unattached MJ 1:40:55 998 186
187 0:24:08 REARDON, Nicole Aghada RC F40 1:47:38 298 187
188 0:24:16 KEARNEY, Brian Unattached M 2:41:16 977 188
189 0:24:18 LENIHAN, Pamela Fota Island AC F35 2:54:40 162 189
190 0:24:32 CRONIN, Sorcha Unattached FJ 4:28:32 57 190
191 0:24:33 SMIDDY, Maura Unattached F40 4:35:14 991 191
192 0:24:34 DUNNE, Kathleen Unattached F70 4:41:56 80 192
193 0:24:36 HAYES, Emer Midleton AC F50 4:55:21 107 193
194 0:24:38 BARRY, Margaret Midleton AC F65 5:08:45 9 194
195 0:24:40 CRONIN, Nessa Unattached FJ 5:22:10 55 195
196 0:24:41 CRONIN, Mark Midleton AC M40 5:28:52 54 196
197 0:24:43 COAKLEY, Michael West Waterford AC M55 5:42:16 30 197
198 0:24:44 COLLINS, Caoimhe Unattached FJ 5:48:59 386 198
199 0:24:44 BAILY, Colette Ballinacurra Villagers AC F55 5:48:59 6 199
200 0:24:45 BARRY, Tuiren Unattached FJ 5:55:41 996 200
201 0:24:53 BROWNE, Deirdre Unattached F45 6:49:19 377 201
202 0:25:06 CABALL, Billy Rising Sun AC M75 8:16:28 984 202
203 0:25:12 QUINN, Annette Unattached F40 8:56:42 295 203
204 0:25:13 CARROLL, Miriam Unattached F40 9:03:24 25 204
205 0:25:17 KEANE, Mary Unattached F50 9:30:13 137 205
206 0:25:22 WARE, Rhona Aghada RC F45 0:03:44 346 206
207 0:25:22 CONWAY, Linda Aghada RC F40 0:03:44 37 207
208 0:25:27 SLOAN, Suzanne Midleton AC F45 0:37:15 318 208
209 0:25:33 O'NEILL, Joanne Unattached F 1:17:29 265 209
210 0:25:33 O'NEILL, Emma Unattached F 1:17:29 965 210
211 0:25:41 CRONIN, Erin Ballinacurra Villagers AC F 2:11:07 50 211
212 0:25:42 BALDWIN, Faye Ballinacurra Villagers AC F35 2:17:49 7 212
213 0:25:42 RYAN, Rosemary Unattached F45 2:17:49 313 213
214 0:25:44 MCGRATH, Marie Unattached F45 2:31:14 184 214
215 0:25:45 CRONIN, Helen Unattached F40 2:37:56 51 215
216 0:25:45 CROWLEY, Ciaran Unattached MJ 2:37:56 62 216
217 0:25:46 CROWLEY, Avril Unattached F45 2:44:38 60 217
218 0:25:56 WALSH, Paul Unattached M45 3:51:41 960 218
219 0:25:57 CRONIN, Marie Unattached F40 3:58:23 53 219
220 0:25:57 O'REGAN, Louise Aghada RC F40 3:58:23 272 220
221 0:25:58 CUNNINGHAM, Gwen Aghada RC F45 4:05:05 64 221
222 0:26:09 HENNESSY, Adam Unattached MJ 5:18:50 993 222
223 0:26:09 CUNNINGHAM, Siobhan Aghada RC F45 5:18:50 65 223
224 0:26:10 LESNIEWSKI, Peter Unattached M 5:25:32 164 224
225 0:26:20 KENNEFICK, Mary Unattached F50 6:32:35 147 225
226 0:26:21 MCCARTHY, Ann Unattached F50 6:39:17 175 226
227 0:26:25 VON HEYNE, Heike Ballymore Cobh AC F40 7:06:06 338 227
228 0:26:27 WIMPENNY, Aine Unattached F45 7:19:30 352 228
229 0:26:28 HORGAN CERNY, Ruth Unattached F45 7:26:13 124 229
230 0:26:30 RONAN, Eileen Unattached F55 7:39:37 952 230
231 0:26:31 COTTER, Jean Unattached F 7:46:19 988 231
232 0:26:34 O'SHEA, Miriam Unattached F45 8:06:26 278 232
233 0:26:40 O'CONNOR, Catherine Unattached F45 8:46:40 240 233
234 0:26:56 GRIFFIN, Rob Unattached MJ 0:33:56 101 234
235 0:26:57 SMIDDY, Noel Unattached M45 0:40:38 990 235
236 0:26:57 HARTE, Jim Midleton AC M50 0:40:38 105 236
237 0:27:00 GRIFFIN, Edward Unattached M40 1:00:45 100 237
238 0:27:08 MCILVNNA, Martina St Catherines AC F55 1:54:23 186 238
239 0:27:12 O'SULLIVAN, Emer Unattached F40 2:21:12 939 239
240 0:27:15 O'RIORDAN, Noreen Midleton AC F55 2:41:18 275 240
241 0:27:15 WALSH, Antoinette Ballintotis Fit4Life F35 2:41:18 340 241
242 0:27:20 SWORDS, Eva Unattached FJ 3:14:50 324 242
243 0:27:21 SWORDS, Lavina East Cork AC F 3:21:32 966 243
244 0:27:41 BARRY, Kay Unattached F50 5:35:37 956 244
245 0:27:46 WIMPENNY, Ewan Unattached MJ 6:09:08 354 245
246 0:27:49 WATERMAN, Harry Unattached MJ 6:29:15 348 246
247 0:27:51 THOMAS, Lynn Unattached F70 6:42:39 327 247
248 0:27:51 GRIFFIN, Billy Midleton AC M75 6:42:39 99 248
249 0:27:52 MOTHERWAY, Niamh Unattached F 6:49:22 197 249
250 0:27:56 WATERMAN, Jon Unattached M 7:16:11 349 250
251 0:28:02 SWORDS, Hugo Unattached MJ 7:56:24 325 251
252 0:28:03 TAIT, John Aghada RC M60 8:03:06 326 252
253 0:28:04 MURPHY, Margo Unattached F40 8:09:49 210 253
254 0:28:04 MCSWEENEY, Caitriona Unattached F40 8:09:49 189 254
255 0:28:36 O'CONNELL, Kathleen Midleton AC F65 1:44:21 237 255
256 0:29:38 BARRETT, Trish Unattached F 8:40:00 989 256
257 0:30:19 RYAN, Amiee Unattached FJ 3:14:52 307 257
258 0:30:32 RYAN, Joanne Unattached FJ 4:42:02 310 258
259 0:30:53 MORRISSON, Orla St Catherines AC FJ 7:02:49 381 259
260 0:30:54 MORRISON, Marian St Catherines AC F40 7:09:31 195 260
261 0:30:56 SMIDDY, Cian Unattached MJ 7:22:56 992 261
262 0:31:03 MOYNIHAN, Sarah Unattached FJ 8:09:51 931 262
263 0:31:19 CRONIN, Tadhg Unattached MJ 9:57:07 58 263
264 0:31:19 LOONEY, Siobhan Unattached F40 9:57:07 167 264
265 0:31:20 O'LEARY, Claire Aghada RC F40 0:03:50 262 265
266 0:31:20 NORRIS, Ronan Aghada RC MJ 0:03:50 220 266
267 0:31:48 O'CONNELL, Donie Midleton AC M65 3:11:33 236 267
268 0:31:51 MCMURTRY, Jim Midleton AC M70 3:31:39 188 268
269 0:32:02 THOMAS, Shelly Unattached F50 4:45:24 328 269
270 0:33:37 BARRY, Frances Unattached F35 5:22:18 384 270
There were 270 finishers in the All Competitors category.
Results produced by East Cork Athletic Club. Printed by East Cork Athletic Club on 20 January 2019 Page 5 of 5
No comments:
Post a Comment